Israel and Hamas have agreed to the first phase of a U.S.-brokered peace plan that promises the release of hostages, withdrawal of Israeli troops from parts of Gaza, and a surge in humanitarian aid. The announcement triggered spontaneous celebrations in Tel Aviv and Gaza City, with families lighting flares and dancing in the streets after more than 730 days of war. Yet analysts warn the deal remains fragile, with critical details like the timeline for hostage releases and the extent of military pullback still undisclosed. The true test lies not in the handshake, but in what follows.
U.S. President Donald Trump told families of the remaining 48 hostages that their loved ones would return by Monday, October 13. Of those, 20 are believed alive. The release hinges on Israel’s phased withdrawal from large sections of Gaza a condition Hamas has long demanded. While Trump recently posted a map indicating a proposed IDF pullback line, neither side has confirmed the boundaries. Without transparency, trust remains thin.
Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu called the agreement “a great day for Israel,” but his far-right coalition partners Itamar Ben-Gvir and Bezalel Smotrich have already denounced any deal with Hamas as “capitulation.” Their influence could pressure Netanyahu to stall or reverse withdrawals after hostages are freed. Hamas, scarred by the collapse of a March 2025 ceasefire that never led to final talks, insists the international community must enforce compliance. Without guarantees, history may repeat itself.
Despite global skepticism, Donald Trump’s direct engagement appears pivotal. In a Fox News interview, he recounted pressuring Netanyahu: “Israel cannot fight the world, Bibi.” Families of hostages now credit Trump not Netanyahu with securing the deal. His administration’s behind-the-scenes coordination with Qatar and Egypt, coupled with recent international moves toward recognizing Palestinian statehood, may have created the pressure needed to force compromise. Whether this marks a turning point or a temporary pause remains uncertain.
For the 2.3 million Palestinians in Gaza, the ceasefire offers fragile hope but no guarantees. Past agreements collapsed before reconstruction or political talks began. Hamas demands binding commitments on a full Israeli withdrawal and a pathway to Palestinian sovereignty. Without them, the current truce risks becoming another interlude in a protracted war. As one woman walked past rubble in Khan Younis, her silence spoke louder than the distant cheers: survival is not peace.
The current agreement covers only phase one: hostages, aid, and partial withdrawal. The harder questions permanent ceasefire, governance of Gaza, Palestinian statehood remain untouched. International actors, including Australia, see this as a chance to build momentum. But momentum requires follow-through. If the world looks away after the last hostage crosses the border, Gaza’s children will inherit not peace, but another countdown to war. Peace Is Not A Headline It’s A Promise Kept Over Time.
0 Yorumlar